Proofreading vs. Editing: Why Your Manuscript Needs Both
- sehar rollingauthors
- Apr 4
- 3 min read
Updated: 2 days ago

Writing a book is indeed a labor of love. You spend days and nights fleshing out characters and nurturing thoughts in a bid to ensure your message gets conveyed to the world out there. However, even the most talented authors usually require a second pair of eyes. Proofreading and editing are just the things! Just as one polishes a diamond to bring out its shine, so too must your manuscript receive a hard polish in the editing stage to shine through. Here is why:
Every Book Needs a Clear Narrative Flow: Whether writing fiction or nonfiction, the book should feel interesting, well-structured, and logical. The editing process not only corrects grammar and inaccurate spelling but also smoothes transitions to provide logical flow and ensures cohesion in the chapters in the big picture.
Invisible Clutter That Slows Readers Down: Would you keep reading a book that contains unnecessary words, redundant phrases, and over-long explanations? Probably not. Your readers feel the same way. Redundancies and filler words make slogging through your piece easier, but good editing removes all of them, leaving your story or thoughts fresher and more powerful.
Your Tone Might Be Working Against You: The tone of a novel needs to be compatible with its genre: in nonfiction, it must not be too formal or too informal. The editing stage checks for consistency in a way so that your voice fits the theme of the book and speaks to its audience.
Fiction and Nonfiction Need Both for Fact-Checking: Misinformation in nonfiction can be damaging to your credibility, whereas a character having his eyes described in two different colors midway through a novel just pulls the reader out of the story. Editing will help catch those inconsistencies in your book, thereby bolstering its integrity.
Reader's Experience Above All: You know your book in and out, but have you ever thought about what it feels like for that poor soul reading it for the first time? Editing helps sharpen pacing, clarify issues, and develop a seamless experience for your reader. Fine reading is not a given; it has been thoroughly polished and edited to become so.
The Different Stages of Editing
While many authors consider editing as a single stop-the-process, it is in fact made up of various layers of refinements:
Developmental Editing: This looks at the big picture and considers story structure, plot holes, pacing, and character development.
Line Editing: Focuses on the readability of every sentence, shape sentences into flowing words, and select the style.
Copyedits: For grammar corrections, tone consistency, and compliance with all style guides.
Proofreading: The last stage catching typos, punctuation errors, and formatting inconsistencies prior to publication.
All of these stages of editing are essential to refining a manuscript into a polished book that welcomes its reader.
Why It Is Worth Your Investment to Hire a Professional Editor?
Self-editing is an essential phase, but a professional editor will provide an objective eye that the author will invariably miss. Here are explanations for the professional editing expense:
Fresh Eyes Catch More Errors: After spending months working on your manuscript, your brain tends to auto-correct your errors, and thus makes it very hard to spot them.
The Editor Knows the Industry: The editors know what the industry expects and the norms for each genre, so your book will meet the industry standard.
Constructive Feedback: Professional editors help strengthen a manuscript by giving constructive feedback on areas that could be improved while respecting the author's voice.
Self-Editing Before Sending to an Editor
Investing time in self-editing before sending your manuscript to an editor can save money and strengthen your draft in numerous ways. Here are a few quick tips:
Take a Break: Detach yourself from your manuscript for a few days before coming back to it with some well-deserved fresh eyes.
Read It Aloud: The old skill of reading out loud helps one catch awkward phrasing, unnatural dialogue, and pacing problems.
Editing Software: Tools such as Grammarly, ProWritingAid, or Hemingway Editor can identify common grammatical mistakes. But make sure to not completely rely upon them as they can give incorrect suggestions sometimes.
Print It Up: Somehow, errors jump out from a printed copy that might otherwise be missed on the screen.
Work Backwards: Looking at your manuscript from the last paragraph to the first breaks the story and makes it easier to deal with sentence-level corrections.
Editing and proofreading are the last but terribly important steps in the publishing process. A well-edited book enhances readability and establishes your credibility as an author. Whether you are self-editing, hiring a professional to help, or doing a mix of both, polishing your manuscript would give it a proper chance to shine in the eyes of readers as an outcome of your hard work.
Want your manuscript to be flawlessly perfect? Visit us at www.rollingauthors.com
Read 'Red Flags in a Ghostwriter' https://www.rollingauthors.com/post/red-flags-in-a-ghostwriter
Comments